Contact Us: 813-597-6400

Menu

Social Security Is Already Broke and Politicians Want to Speed Up the Collapse

, , ,

The Math Does Not Lie

Social Security is heading toward a cliff. We are talking about a projected benefit cut of nearly 25% within a few short years. That is not a rumor. That is not partisan spin. That is the math, and nobody in Washington is seriously addressing it. So what does Congress do in response? Introduce a bill that would make the problem dramatically worse.

Representative Haley Stevens, a Democrat from Michigan, introduced the Blue Collar Social Security Fairness Act. The bill would allow workers in physically demanding occupations to claim full Social Security retirement benefits starting at age 60. Right now the earliest you can claim is 62, with full benefits kicking in at 67. Dropping eligibility to 60 for a broad category of workers accelerates the cash drain on an already underfunded system.

A Half-Baked Idea With No Other Side

Here is where I have to be honest with you. I have actually talked about the concept of tiered retirement ages before. There is a legitimate conversation to be had about workers who spend decades doing physically brutal work. Construction workers, roofers, nurses on their feet for 12-hour shifts. These people age differently than someone in a climate-controlled office.

But here is the critical point everyone is ignoring. Any equation has two sides. If you are going to let certain workers retire earlier, drawing from the Social Security trust fund longer, you have to offset that somewhere. The most logical place is to raise the retirement age for workers in less physically demanding roles. Office workers. Government employees. People who are not breaking their bodies for a living.

This bill does none of that. It is one side of the ledger with nothing on the other.

We Have Seen This Movie Before

I covered the European financial crisis extensively, and this conversation takes me right back to Greece. The Greeks allowed workers in all kinds of loosely defined “dangerous” professions to retire with full government pensions at absurdly early ages. Hairdressers qualified because they worked around chemicals. The system collapsed under the weight of it.

Now look at how the Bureau of Labor Statistics defines physically demanding work under this proposed bill:

  • Climbing
  • Heavy lifting
  • Pushing and pulling
  • Standing for extended periods
  • Walking

Under that definition, mail carriers qualify. Think about how many occupations could fit under that umbrella once the lobbying starts. The bill calls for the qualifying occupation list to be updated every three years, which means the list only ever grows.

What Retirement Planning Looks Like in This Environment

If you are counting on Social Security as a meaningful piece of your retirement income, this is exactly why you cannot afford to wait and see how Congress sorts this out. They are not sorting it out. They are actively making it worse.

Here is what I think every working American should be doing right now:

  • Plan around a reduced Social Security benefit. Model your retirement assuming benefits come in at 75 to 80 cents on the dollar, not the full amount.
  • Accelerate your personal savings rate. The gap between what Social Security will pay and what you need has to come from somewhere.
  • Understand your full retirement age. The difference between claiming at 62 versus 67 is enormous. Know what each option costs you over a 20-year retirement.
  • Stop assuming the government will fix this. The evidence suggests they will not.

The Real Threat

China gets a lot of attention as an existential threat. So does inflation. So does the deficit. But the thing that genuinely keeps me up at night is the quality of the decision-making coming out of Washington on issues like this. A system that is already mathematically unsound is being treated like a political tool, not a financial obligation to the American people.

The Blue Collar Social Security Fairness Act is not fairness. It is a bill that trades a real solution for a press release. And the people who will pay for it are the millions of Americans who are counting on that money being there when they need it.

Related Posts